PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has said that the system did not collapse on its own but was deliberately destroyed. In other words, it was not a natural death but a murder. On reflection, the argument does raise a question: how could a system in which so many people have been working for so many years have collapsed by accident? Surely, someone must have put considerable effort into bringing it down.

The problem, however, is that the person demanding an investigation also has the keys to the victim’s room.

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar made a similar point, arguing that political parties have been part of the system for decades and cannot distance themselves from its shortcomings.

Talal Chaudhry went a step further, pointing out that the PPP has influence over nearly 70 per cent of the country’s government structure. Hearing this, one might wonder whether the person reporting the murder is also a witness, perhaps even an informant, and has a place on the list of heirs.

But fairness demands that we also examine how high the ruling party’s name appears on that list. Those who now sit in government and insist that the system is functioning properly were, until recently, standing on the other side and complaining about its failures. In Pakistan, the system always appears healthy to those in power and critically ill to those in opposition. The only difference is the pair of glasses they wear. The patient remains the same.

There is another name in this discussion: the very person often described as Bilawal’s ‘brother’ and considered a friend of Shehbaz Sharif — Mohsin Naqvi, who was among the first to speak about a ‘system reset’.

Many believe that although Naqvi is a minister in Shehbaz Sharif’s cabinet, he is also working on someone else’s assignment. My view is that whoever he is working for appears to have considerable control over the system. But let us return to Bilawal.

He also made an interesting observation, saying that the PTI is a political reality and that the country cannot function without it. There is no reason to dispute that point. It is worth remembering, however, that the same political reality was once described by his party as a source of ‘chaos’. In 2022, that very reality was removed from power through a vote in parliament.

Political realities change with the seasons. The difference is that, at least with the weather, the Meteorological Department provides a forecast.

And 2022 is not the only example. In October 2026, the PTI government in a province was removed and governor’s rule imposed. The governor belonged to the PPP, while the president who signed the order was Bilawal’s father.

This is precisely why the PTI describes the PPP’s position as hypocrisy. Its grievances may be understandable, but the question is whether hypocrisy is exclusive to one political party. The party protesting today while presenting itself as a victim is also accused of having benefited from the same system in the past. It was not always opposed to the system it now criticises. Its flaws apparently became visible only when the keys were taken away.

And what about the establishment? As usual, it remains silent amid the entire spectacle. After all, the landlord does not get involved in disputes between tenants. It simply watches to see whether the property remains secure.

Ultimately, the question remains: where are the people in all this?

The answer is that the public is neither the complainant, nor the accused, nor a witness in this case. It is merely the reserved seat everyone wants to occupy, without anyone having to answer to its occupants.

Whether the system died naturally or was deliberately killed is a question history will eventually answer. Until then, we will continue listening to condolence statements, each ending with the same promise: ‘The killers will be exposed.’

And if the killer is ever unmasked, perhaps we will discover that it was the very key everyone had been carrying in their pocket.