The hearing focused partly on eight suicide attempts aboard an aircraft carrier and offered an early indication of the tougher congressional scrutiny the Trump administration could face from January, when Democrats are set to take control of Congress following their victories in this month's midterm elections.
Cao, who is seeking Senate confirmation to retain his position, faced questions from the Senate Armed Services Committee but avoided addressing several key issues surrounding the conflict.
Lawmakers questioned him about the financial cost of the US naval blockade against Iran and damage caused by Iranian attacks on the Navy’s Middle East headquarters.
However, the strongest criticism came over his defence of conditions aboard the Abraham Lincoln carrier strike group and his praise for the Navy’s response to sailors’ mental health concerns.
Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, a Democrat from New York, questioned Cao about a sailor who had gone overboard.
Cao said the sailor was not attempting suicide and had acknowledged this, adding that he had used a life preserver.
Gillibrand challenged his explanation, asking what the sailor had been trying to do and suggesting that Cao was minimising the mental health pressures faced by service members.
She described his response as “inhumane” and “inadequate”.
Republican Representative Rob Wittman of Virginia, who introduced Cao at the hearing, praised his personal journey, describing him as a remarkable American story.
Cao arrived in the United States as a refugee from Vietnam and served in the Navy for 25 years, including deployments to Iraq, Afghanistan and Somalia. He retired with the rank of captain.
His son currently serves in the Marine Corps.
Cao told lawmakers he wanted to lead the Navy to ensure sailors did not face the same difficulties experienced by US troops during the Iraq War, when many lacked armoured vehicles and adequate body armour.
Senator Angus King, an independent from Maine who caucuses with Democrats, praised Cao’s personal story but pointed to what he described as a contradiction in the Trump administration’s immigration policies.
King noted that the administration was reducing refugee admissions and said Cao’s family might not have been allowed into the United States under current policies.
Senators question Navy recruitment standards
Republican Senator Tom Cotton of Arkansas dismissed claims about poor conditions aboard Navy ships, arguing that the service had achieved its recruitment targets three months ahead of schedule.
He asked whether the situation could really be as serious as Democrats had suggested if the Navy was meeting its recruitment goals.
Cao agreed that the recruitment figures indicated otherwise.
However, Senator Jack Reed, a Democrat from Rhode Island, cited data suggesting that most new Navy recruits required waivers from standard eligibility requirements, including those related to mental health.
Reed questioned whether the Navy was prioritising recruitment numbers over the quality of its personnel. Cao rejected the suggestion.
Cao himself will require a waiver to secure Senate confirmation because he retired from the Navy in 2021, less than the required seven-year cooling-off period for becoming its civilian leader.
Iran war faces growing political pressure
Public anger over the Iran war, which has reached an effective stalemate centred on control of the Strait of Hormuz, helped Democrats secure control of Congress.
A Reuters/Ipsos poll published last week found that a majority of Americans wanted the incoming Democratic-majority Congress to take action to bring the conflict to an end.
The US Navy has played a major role in the war by enforcing a naval blockade against Iran and supporting strikes on Iranian territory.
A third US aircraft carrier entered Middle Eastern waters this week, although officials said it was expected to replace one of the two carriers already deployed in the region.
The US military has highlighted the damage inflicted on Iran’s conventional military capabilities and its efforts to help escort tankers through the Strait of Hormuz.
However, the Pentagon has yet to explain how it expects the conflict to end.
Senator Tammy Duckworth, a Democrat from Illinois, also questioned whether Cao had ever challenged Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth over the administration’s Iran war policy.
Cao replied that doing so was outside his responsibilities.
Duckworth rejected his answer, accusing him of failing to demonstrate leadership and describing him as a potential “yes-man” for the Trump administration.







